Skip to content

Call or text (413) 426-8657
Dunn & Phillips, P.C.

Comparative Fault in the Northeast: Where Massachusetts Draws the Line

Personal Injury

Can you still get paid if the accident was partly your fault? In Massachusetts, yes, as long as you were not more at fault than the other side. The law lowers what you get by your share of the blame. It cuts you off only when your share is greater than everyone else's added together. At exactly 50%, you still collect half.

Cross a state line and the answer changes. Two neighbors pay you something at any level of fault. One cuts you off as soon as the fault is even. The map below shows all nine Northeast states. The rest of this post explains what the Massachusetts rule means for an injury claim in Springfield or Westfield.

Map of the nine Northeast states (Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, New Hampshire, Vermont, Maine, New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania) with Massachusetts highlighted.
Nine states, three rules. Two let you recover at any level of fault (NY, RI). Six cut you off once your share is greater than everyone else's (MA, CT, NH, VT, NJ, PA). One cuts you off at equal fault (ME).

How Massachusetts law treats shared fault

Massachusetts uses a rule lawyers call modified comparative negligence. Negligence means not using reasonable care. The rule is in one law, M.G.L. c. 231, § 85, and it comes down to three points.

  1. The rule. A jury gives each side a percentage of the fault. You can recover money as long as your negligence is not greater than the total negligence of the people you are suing, added together. Fifty percent recovers; fifty-one does not.
  2. The reduction. If you are under the line, your award goes down by your share. If a jury awards $100,000 and puts 20% of the fault on you, you get $80,000.
  3. Who decides. Insurance adjusters, the people who decide claims for insurance companies, assign fault first. They assign it in their own favor. A jury decides only if the case goes that far. Most cases settle, so the adjuster's number is usually the one that matters.

If it was a car accident, Massachusetts no-fault rules add steps of their own. Our car accident page explains how they work.

The Northeast, state by state

In the table, "barred" means you get nothing.

State Rule What it means for you Authority
Massachusetts Modified comparative Barred only if your negligence is greater than the total of the people you sue. 50% still recovers. M.G.L. c. 231, § 85
Connecticut Modified comparative Barred if yours is greater than the combined negligence of the people you sue. 50% recovers. C.G.S. § 52-572h
Rhode Island Pure comparative No bar. Your damages go down by your share, whatever it is. R.I. Gen. Laws § 9-20-4
New Hampshire Modified comparative Barred if yours is greater than the fault of the people you sue, added together. 50% recovers. RSA 507:7-d
Vermont Modified comparative Barred if yours is greater than the causal total negligence of the people you sue. 50% recovers. 12 V.S.A. § 1036
Maine Modified, equal-fault bar Barred if you are equally at fault. Otherwise the jury lowers your award by a dollar amount it finds just and fair, not by a strict percentage. 14 M.R.S. § 156
New York Pure comparative, one carve-out No bar in general. In auto injury cases under the no-fault law, barred if your culpable conduct (blameworthy conduct) is greater than the combined conduct of the people you sue. CPLR 1411(a), (b)
New Jersey Modified comparative Barred if yours is greater than the combined negligence of the people you sue. 50% recovers. N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1
Pennsylvania Modified comparative Barred if yours is greater than the combined causal negligence of all the people you sue. Equal fault recovers. 42 Pa.C.S. § 7102

Two details change the answer in crashes with several cars. Most of these states compare your fault to that of all the people you sue, added together. New Hampshire and Connecticut also count people who have settled and people who are immune, meaning the law protects them from being sued, in that total. New Jersey and Pennsylvania also use a separate 60% line. It decides whether one defendant pays the whole judgment or only its share. That is a different question from whether you recover at all.

Hurt in a neighboring state? Where the crash happened usually matters most. But a Massachusetts court looks at every state's connection to the case before it decides whose law applies. So get advice before you assume which rule you are under.

Why two percentage points decide everything

Same crash, same $100,000 verdict, four jurisdictions, meaning four places with their own laws.

Fault assigned to you Massachusetts Rhode Island, or New York outside auto cases New York auto case Maine
49% $51,000 $51,000 $51,000 Jury sets a just and fair dollar reduction
50% $50,000 $50,000 $50,000 $0
51% $0 $49,000 $0 $0

In Massachusetts, the fight over a few percentage points is the whole case. That is what the adjuster is doing when the first letter says you were "partly responsible." These things can move the number: the police report, witness statements, photos, dash-cam video, and anything the other driver admitted at the scene.

What to do in the first week

In the first week, fault gets assigned in an informal way, and it is hard to change later. Every step below protects your percentage.

  1. Do not give a recorded statement to the other side's insurance company. Every "I guess I could have..." becomes a percentage.
  2. Get the police report number and ask for the report.
  3. Take photos of everything that shows what the other side did: skid marks, the traffic signal, the dog's fenced area, the wet floor with no sign.
  4. Write down the names of witnesses before they leave.
  5. See a doctor and follow the treatment plan. Gaps in treatment get read as "not that hurt," and that carries over into arguments about fault too.
  6. Call a lawyer before you talk to the adjuster, not after.

Fees

We take injury cases on a contingency fee, and there is no upfront cost. At your free consultation, we explain the percentage and what happens with case expenses.

Why people across Massachusetts call Dunn & Phillips

Offices at 185 Belmont Avenue, Springfield and 56 Washington Street, Westfield, with off-street parking in Westfield. A 24-hour injury line at (413) 426-8657. In-house help in Spanish, Turkish, Russian, Ukrainian, Chinese, and French. Serving injured people across Massachusetts for over 30 years.

This post is general information about the law of Massachusetts and nearby states as of October 2026. It is not legal advice about your situation. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Attorney Advertising. Dunn & Phillips, P.C., 185 Belmont Ave, Springfield, MA 01108 · 56 Washington St, Westfield, MA 01085.

Discuss your matter
Have us call you

Frequently asked questions

In Massachusetts, can I get paid if the accident was partly my fault?
Yes, if you were not more at fault than the other side. Massachusetts lowers your award by your share of the fault. It cuts your award to zero only if you go past the 50% line. The insurance company will try to push your share up. Do not give a recorded statement. Get the police report and photos. Talk to a lawyer before you agree to any fault percentage.
What happens if the insurance company says I was 50% at fault?
In Massachusetts, 50% still gets paid. You lose only if you are more than 50% at fault, not at 50%. So if the fault is split evenly, you get half of your damages. Adjusters, the people who work on claims for the insurance company, sometimes round up to push you over the line. Challenge their split in writing. Ask what evidence it is based on. Do not sign a release until the percentage is settled.
Who decides what percentage of fault I have?
Usually the adjuster, unless you push back. In Massachusetts, a jury makes the final decision at trial. The jury compares your negligence to that of all the defendants, the people you are suing, added together. But most claims settle before trial. The adjuster's first number is a starting offer, not a final decision. Build your proof early: the report, photos, witnesses, and medical records that match what you say happened.
I live in Massachusetts but was hurt in Connecticut, New York, or New Hampshire. Which rule applies?
Usually the law of the state where you were hurt, but not always. A Massachusetts court asks which state has the closest connection to the case. The answer can change the whole claim. A Springfield driver hit on I-87 faces New York's auto-case bar at 51%, while a pedestrian hit on a New York sidewalk faces no bar at all. Call before you assume.
Does comparative fault apply to slip and fall and dog bite cases, or only car accidents?
Yes, it applies to almost every injury claim. Massachusetts uses the same c. 231, § 85 comparison whether you fell in a store, were bitten, or were rear-ended. Only the car-accident no-fault threshold applies just to motor vehicles. Property owners and dog owners argue that you should have seen the danger. Take photos of the scene, and of the missing warnings, the same day.
Can my own insurance company use my fault percentage against me?
Not for PIP (personal injury protection), which pays no matter who was at fault. Massachusetts no-fault coverage pays your early medical bills and lost wages whether or not you caused the crash. Fault matters again if you make a claim on your own uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage. That claim is measured the same way as a claim against the other driver would be. Check your declarations page, the first page of your policy, and call.
Is there a deadline to dispute a fault finding?
What matters is the deadline for your claim. There is no separate deadline to dispute fault. In Massachusetts, most personal injury lawsuits must be filed within three years of the injury (M.G.L. c. 260, § 2A). The clock can start later only in narrow cases where you could not reasonably have known you were harmed. Do not wait for the adjuster to finish arguing about percentages. Call in the first year, not the third.

These answers are general information, not legal advice, and do not create an attorney-client relationship.

Discuss your matter

Questions about a deadline or a potential claim are best answered early. An initial conversation with the firm is confidential and without obligation.

Tell us what happened

The first conversation is free. You'll leave knowing where you stand.

Have us call you

Free. A real person calls you back.

A very brief description of your inquiry is fine. The use of this site, this communication form, or contact with any member of this firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Please do not submit or transmit confidential or time-sensitive information: what you send is not treated as confidential and does not prevent us from representing someone else in the same matter. By submitting this form, you consent to being contacted by Dunn & Phillips, P.C. and accept our terms of use and privacy policy.

This form is for people looking for legal help. We do not accept sales, marketing or vendor solicitations through it. Advertising, sponsorship and vendor inquiries: please use our business inquiries page.

Call or text (413) 426-8657. Answered live, 24 hours a day.

We use Google Analytics to understand how this site is used; it sets cookies. Embedded maps may set their own when you load them. Cookie Notice | Privacy Policy.