Short answer: The dog’s owner or keeper is usually the person legally responsible. But the money often comes from their homeowner’s, renter’s or other liability insurance, if it applies.
The claim usually goes to an insurance company before anyone asks the owner to pay out of pocket. Whether the claim is covered depends on the whole policy, its limits, what it leaves out (its exclusions), and whether the insured person owned or kept the dog. If no policy applies, the owner or keeper may still have to pay personally.
Your health insurance may process the first medical bills while the claim is open. If you were bitten while working, workers’ compensation may be another possible source. If you later get money from the dog claim, rights to be paid back or liens may have to be dealt with. A lien is a legal right to be paid back from that money.
Dunn & Phillips, P.C. has represented injured people in Massachusetts for over 30 years. A real person answers our injury line 24 hours a day at (413) 426-8657.
Who pays for a dog bite in Massachusetts
The dog’s owner, its keeper, or an insurance company whose policy applies may pay. More than one person may have owned, had, housed, managed or controlled the dog. Each of them, and the place where it happened, may have its own insurance policy.
| Who may pay | What it pays | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Homeowner’s or renter’s liability insurance | Covered losses caused by an insured owner or keeper, under the policy’s terms | When the responsible person is insured, and the dog, the place, what happened and the losses claimed are all covered |
| A landlord’s or other keeper’s insurance | Covered losses based on that person’s own legal responsibility | When the person counts as a keeper or may have been careless (negligent) on their own, and the policy covers the claim |
| Your health insurance | Medical bills it processes under your health plan | While the claim against the owner is still open, under your plan’s terms. Your plan may have a right to be paid back |
| Workers’ compensation | Medical care for a work injury, and other benefits the workers’ compensation system allows | When you were hurt because of your job, while doing your job |
| The owner personally | Losses the law lets you recover that insurance does not pay | When no policy applies, the coverage is not enough, or an insurance company denies coverage |
Insurance coverage and legal responsibility are different questions. A person may be legally responsible even when an insurance company says the policy does not cover the loss.
What is strict liability?
Strict liability means you generally do not have to prove that an owner or keeper was careless (negligent) or knew the dog was dangerous. Massachusetts law says a keeper is a person or organization, other than the owner, that has possession of the dog. Courts also look at who had custody of the dog, who managed it and who controlled it. This matters because an owner and one or more keepers may each be responsible, and each may have a different insurance policy. For the rules on strict liability, defenses and children, see our Dog Bite Injuries page under Personal Injury.
Who pays if the dog belongs to my friend or relative?
Your friend’s or relative’s insurance company may pay, without that person having to write you a personal check. A homeowner’s or renter’s liability claim is made against the policy. But whether it is covered depends on what the policy actually says.
Common questions are: where the dog usually lived, who took care of it, and whether your friend or relative had a homeowner’s, condo, renter’s or umbrella policy. An umbrella policy is extra liability insurance on top of other policies. The policy for the home may not be the only one that applies. Another person in the household, or someone who controlled the dog, may also have been a keeper.
Someone saying there is no coverage is not the same as the insurance company deciding there is none.
Who pays if the dog lives with a tenant?
If the tenant owns and controls the dog, the tenant or the tenant’s insurance company is usually the first place to look. A landlord does not become the dog’s keeper just by owning the property or by now and then seeing or dealing with the dog.
In some situations, a landlord may still face a separate negligence claim, meaning a claim that the landlord was careless. The important facts include where it happened; whether the injured person was a tenant, a guest or someone passing by; whether the landlord knew of a danger; and whether the landlord had a reasonable chance and the legal power to deal with it. Massachusetts appeals court decisions do not make a landlord automatically liable for every injury caused by a tenant’s dog.
The tenant’s renter’s policy and the landlord’s liability policy can be separate sources of payment. The lease, written complaints, notices and animal-control records can show what the landlord knew.
Who pays if I was bitten at work or while making a delivery?
Workers’ compensation may pay first if you were bitten while doing your job. This may apply to delivery workers, home health workers, utility workers, repair workers and others whose jobs take them onto property where a dog is present.
The workers’ compensation claim and the claim against the dog’s owner or keeper are not always the same claim. If more than one source pays for the same loss, questions about paying one of them back may come up.
Who pays if the dog owner has no insurance?
The owner or keeper may have to pay personally. Under Massachusetts law, an owner or keeper is liable when a dog injures a person or damages property, unless one of the law’s defenses applies.
Even when the owner says there is no insurance, a homeowner’s, renter’s, condo, umbrella, business or other liability policy might apply. More than one person can count as a keeper.
Having a valid claim does not guarantee that the owner can pay personally. What the owner owns and earns is a separate question from who is legally responsible.
Who pays my medical bills while the claim is open?
Your health insurance company may process the bills before the dog claim is resolved. The bills and the explanations of benefits, the statements your health plan sends after it pays, show what treatment you had and who paid for it.
Amounts charged, amounts allowed, payments made and balances owed are often different numbers. A provider or health plan may say it has a lien or a right to be paid back.
In Massachusetts, a medical lien requires certain written notice before a court judgment, a settlement or a compromise. The notice must name the injured person, the date of the incident, the provider, the person said to be responsible, and certain other information.
Does my health insurance get paid back?
Sometimes. It depends on who paid and the legal reason for the payback. The amount on a bill is not always the amount that must be repaid.
MassHealth has rights under state law to recover money when a third party, meaning someone else, pays a claim that includes medical bills. The person making the claim, or their lawyer, must give written notice within 10 calendar days after starting to try to recover money, including making an insurance claim or sending a demand letter. MassHealth must also get notice and a reasonable chance to protect its rights before any recovery becomes final.
Every lien or payback claim has to be dealt with before the final money is divided.
What if the insurer says the policy excludes this dog?
What the policy excludes is decided by the whole policy and the exact exclusion or add-on (endorsement). An exclusion is a part of the policy that says what it does not cover. What an adjuster says out loud is not enough to show what the policy says.
A policy may have an exclusion for dogs, other animals, certain places, household members, business use, or other things. The exact wording and the dates the policy was in effect matter. That wording is spread across the declarations page (the summary page at the front of the policy), the liability section, the definitions, the exclusions, the endorsements, any renewal papers, and any notices canceling or not renewing the policy.
A coverage denial does not erase the owner’s or keeper’s possible legal responsibility. There may still be another policy, another insured keeper, a separate negligence claim, or the owner’s or keeper’s personal responsibility. Which of these exists depends on the facts.
Massachusetts requires an insurance company to give written notice ahead of time if it plans not to renew certain dwelling fire policies. The notice generally must be sent at least 45 days before the policy ends and must give the specific reasons. Canceling a policy in the middle of its term follows different rules under the law.
What a dog owner’s insurance does not pay for
Insurance does not pay a claim that is outside what the policy covers, or that falls under an exclusion that can be enforced. It also does not pay more than the policy limit that applies.
Common arguments are about whether the insured person owned or kept the dog, whether it happened at a place the policy covers, whether an exclusion applies, and whether the policy was in effect. The insurance company may also argue about whether the dog caused the injury or whether a defense under the law applies.
Coverage turns on the whole policy that was in effect on the day of the incident. A declarations page or insurance card is not the whole contract. Every form and endorsement listed on the declarations page is part of it.
When should I talk to a lawyer about a dog bite?
Early, if the injury is serious or the facts are not simple. Some claims are simple enough to settle without a lawyer. A free call is the quickest way to find out which kind yours is.
Dog bite claims get complicated when:
- The injuries are serious or permanent, or there was surgery or scarring
- A child was hurt
- Several people may be keepers, or a landlord may share responsibility
- The bite happened at work
- An insurance company denies responsibility or coverage
- MassHealth, a medical provider or another payer wants to be paid back
- An insurance company asks you to sign a release, which may end the claim even if you need more treatment later
How long do I have?
Do not wait to file. In Massachusetts, a lawsuit over a dog bite generally must be filed within three years of the date of the injury.
Some related deadlines are shorter. A MassHealth member, or their lawyer, must give written notice within 10 calendar days after starting to try to recover money. Insurance policies may also require you to give notice quickly or to cooperate. Claims involving the government may have separate notice rules.
The date of the incident, the injured person’s age, who the responsible party is and the type of claim may affect which deadlines apply.
What should I do first after a dog bite?
Three things protect you whatever happens next.
- Get medical care right away. Our Dog Bite Injuries page under Personal Injury has medical and safety information.
- Keep everything: photos of the injury, the animal-control report, medical bills, and every letter from an insurance company.
- Do not sign a release or give a recorded statement before you have talked to a lawyer.
Some deadlines after a dog bite are short, such as MassHealth’s 10-day notice, so it is worth calling early.
Where we come in
We find everyone who owned or kept the dog and every insurance policy that may apply, and we send the notices the law requires. We ask each insurance company for its coverage decision and the policy it relies on in writing, work out what health plans, MassHealth and others can claim back, and deal with the insurance companies while you recover.
Dog bite lawyers serving Massachusetts
Dunn & Phillips, P.C. serves injured people across Massachusetts.
Talk to us about your bite
Bring the papers that show what happened, what treatment you got, and which insurance companies are involved. Helpful items include photos of the injury, medical bills and explanations of benefits, the animal-control report, the owner’s name and address, and any letter from an insurance company.
Springfield: 185 Belmont Avenue, Springfield, MA 01108
Westfield (Personal Injury Law Center): 56 Washington Street, Westfield, MA 01085
24-hour injury line: (413) 426-8657