Short answer: Yes. If someone else’s negligence, meaning carelessness, caused your brain injury, you can get compensation for it like any other physical injury. You must prove who was responsible, that the event caused the injury, and that the injury caused you real loss.
Medical records are key. A medical opinion or other expert evidence is often important when the cause or effects raise technical medical questions. A normal CT or MRI does not automatically decide the claim.
Dunn & Phillips, P.C. has represented injured people in Massachusetts for over 30 years. A real person answers our injury line 24 hours a day at (413) 426-8657.
Can I get compensation for a concussion or brain injury in Massachusetts?
Yes, if another person or business was negligent and that negligence caused your injury and your losses. A diagnosis alone does not prove who is responsible or what the claim is worth.
A negligence claim needs proof of four things: a duty, a failure to use reasonable care, causation, and real loss. Causation means the failure caused the harm. The evidence you need depends on what happened, how long the effects lasted, and whether the medical issues need an expert to explain them.
| Situation | What usually matters | What decides it |
|---|---|---|
| Concussion with symptoms that cleared up in weeks | Quick medical records, follow-up care, missed work, and how the symptoms affected daily life | Whether you can connect the injury and the losses you have records for to the event |
| Symptoms that lasted months | A steady treatment history, detailed symptom records, opinions from your providers, and proof of changes at work or home | Whether the medical and other evidence proves the effects are continuing and were caused by the event |
| A normal CT or MRI | The full medical record, later check-ups, testing, and what people who know you have noticed | All of the evidence, not the scan result alone |
| A car crash below the pain-and-suffering threshold | How much reasonable and necessary treatment cost, and whether one of the exceptions listed in the law applies | Whether the legal threshold or an exception is proved |
| A child’s head injury | Children’s medical records, school records, changes people noticed, testing, and the special deadline rule for children | Proof of causation and loss, along with the rule that may pause the time to file while the person is a minor |
Your compensation is not based only on the label “concussion” or “brain injury.” It depends on the harm you can prove and whether someone else is legally responsible.
For information about insurance benefits and other car-crash basics, see our Car Accidents page.
What counts as a brain injury in a legal claim?
A brain injury claim may involve a concussion, ongoing problems with thinking, or a severe injury that affects how you function over the long term. The legal issue is not the diagnosis alone. It is whether the evidence connects the condition, and the loss that came from it, to someone else’s negligence.
A concussion that did not last long may be proved with emergency records, follow-up notes, records of missed work, and testimony about the recovery period. A claim about long-lasting changes in memory, focus, behavior, or daily functioning may need more detailed treatment records, testing, and medical opinion.
Severe injuries often involve larger and more complex losses. That does not mean every severe diagnosis leads to the same result. It also does not mean every concussion is a large claim. Each claim depends on who was responsible, causation, how long the effects lasted, limits, and the losses you have records for.
For information about planning for long-term care, protecting benefits, and finding the insurance that is available, see our Catastrophic Injury page.
My scans were normal but I still have symptoms
A normal scan does not automatically end your claim. The legal question is whether all of the evidence proves that the event caused an injury and the loss that came from it.
That evidence includes the medical record of the symptoms you reported: when they began, how often they happen, and what activities they affect. The imaging report is part of the record even when the result was normal.
A scan does not prove more than it shows. It is read together with the rest of the medical record. If causation involves medical questions outside everyday experience, a medical opinion may be needed.
I hit my head in a car crash
You may have a claim if another driver’s negligence caused the crash, your injury, and your losses. In many motor vehicle cases, Massachusetts puts an extra limit on damages for pain and suffering.
To get pain-and-suffering damages, you generally need more than $2,000 in reasonable and necessary treatment costs. This threshold does not apply when the injury causes death, or includes a broken bone, loss of a body part, permanent and serious disfigurement, or a loss of sight or hearing that qualifies under the law.
A concussion does not automatically count as one of these exceptions. Your medical costs may go over the threshold, but the bills must still be for reasonable and necessary treatment of the condition the crash caused.
For Personal Injury Protection benefits, coverage questions, and car-crash basics, see our Car Accidents page.
I fell and hit my head on someone’s property
You need proof that the property owner or another responsible person failed to use reasonable care, and that this failure caused your fall and your injury. The injury itself does not prove that the property was unsafe or that someone was negligent.
Photos or video of the condition, the place and date, witnesses, and any incident report can show what happened. Guessing about why a fall happened is not enough to prove causation.
Fault may also be disputed. Under Massachusetts comparative negligence law, which divides fault among the people involved, you can recover if your negligence was not greater than the combined negligence of the people you are seeking money from. Any award is reduced by your share of the negligence.
My memory and mood changed after the injury
Problems with memory, focus, sleep, irritability, or mood are proved the same way as other effects of the injury. Changes mentioned only to family members leave no medical record of them or of when they began.
Specific examples show the change better than general statements. These may include missed appointments, mistakes at work, concerns at school, or trouble doing familiar tasks.
People who knew you before the event may help describe changes they saw for themselves: what they saw, when they saw it, and how it was different from how you were before. A medical opinion may still be needed to connect those changes to the injury.
How do you prove a brain injury?
You prove it by connecting four points: someone owed you a duty of care, that person failed to use reasonable care, the failure caused your injury, and the injury caused you real loss.
The records from your treatment come first. Emergency records may show the first report of symptoms and the exam done after the event. Follow-up records may show whether symptoms went away, changed, or continued.
Neuropsychological testing may be considered when thinking, memory, attention, or other functions are disputed. A qualified professional must explain how useful a test is and what it means. A test result should not be treated as a legal conclusion on its own.
People who knew you before the injury can describe changes they noticed afterward. What they say does not replace medical evidence when the question of cause needs medical expertise.
Bills, payment records, and work, pay and school records can show the losses you claim.
In some situations, Massachusetts law may let medical opinions be shown through qualifying medical records instead of live testimony in court. Whether the records are enough depends on what they say and what medical issue must be proved.
What will the insurer argue?
The insurance company may argue that the evidence does not prove causation or loss. Common disputes involve normal scans, gaps in treatment, earlier medical conditions, and symptoms described in different ways at different times.
When an insurance company relies on normal imaging, the complete medical record, not one report, is the evidence that answers it. When there is a gap in treatment, what matters is the real reason and whether a record supports it.
An earlier condition or similar symptoms are part of the history the claim has to account for. A claim that an injury made an earlier condition worse is more likely to need medical testimony. The opinion must show more than a possibility or a guess.
What can a brain injury claim include?
A claim can ask for compensation for real losses the injury caused. Depending on the evidence, the losses you claim may include reasonable treatment costs, lost income, pain and suffering, and effects on your daily life.
A claim cannot include losses that are not related to the event, that are only guesses, or that the evidence does not support. It also cannot assume that a concussion is worth a certain amount just because of the diagnosis.
In a motor vehicle case, the separate pain-and-suffering threshold may limit that part of the claim, even when there are treatment costs or other losses.
The earliest medical record that describes what happened and what symptoms you reported helps show timing. The complete record says more than the discharge summary, the paper you get when you leave the hospital.
When should I talk to a lawyer about a brain injury?
Early, if symptoms continue or the facts are not simple. Some claims are simple enough to settle without a lawyer. A free call is the quickest way to find out which kind yours is.
Brain injury claims get complicated when:
- Symptoms continue or get worse
- Your work, school, memory, or daily functioning has changed
- A child was hurt
- The insurance company disputes causation
- You had similar symptoms before the event
- People disagree about who was at fault
- The claim needs medical or other expert testimony
- A deadline to file may be close
A release is a paper that settles your claim. A signed release is final: it ends the claim, even if your symptoms later get worse.
How long do I have?
The usual Massachusetts deadline is three years after a personal injury claim accrues, meaning legally begins. Making an insurance claim or talking about the case with an insurance company is not the same as starting a lawsuit.
The usual time limit may change when another law applies. A claim against a city or town generally must be presented, meaning given to it in writing, within two years. Not every claim has the same schedule.
For a child, Massachusetts law may pause the usual time to file while the child is a minor. The exact deadline depends on when the claim accrued, when the legal disability (such as being a minor) ended, and whether another rule applies.
An adult’s mental illness may also affect the time to file if the person was incapacitated, meaning unable to act, for that reason when the claim first accrued. A serious injury alone does not show that this rule applies.
What should I do first after a possible brain injury?
Three things protect you whatever happens next.
- Get medical care, and describe the event and every symptom accurately.
- Keep everything: test reports even when the result is called normal, photos, incident reports, bills, pay records, and every letter from an insurance company.
- Do not sign a release or give a recorded statement before you have talked to a lawyer.
Some deadlines are shorter than the usual three years, such as for a claim against a city or town, so it is worth calling early.
Where we come in
We gather the complete medical record, from the first emergency visit on, along with the test results and the work and school records that show what changed. We look for every person and insurance policy that may be responsible, ask for photos, video and other evidence to be kept, track the deadlines, and deal with the insurance companies, so you can concentrate on getting better.
Brain injury lawyers serving Massachusetts
Dunn & Phillips, P.C. serves injured people and families across Massachusetts.
The firm helps people in Springfield, Westfield, Chicopee, Holyoke, West Springfield, Agawam, Ludlow, Longmeadow, Northampton, Amherst, and communities across Massachusetts.
A claim may involve a concussion that has healed, ongoing symptoms, or a severe injury. The starting point is the same: find out what happened, identify who is responsible, and gather the evidence needed to prove causation and loss.
Talk to us about the injury
Bring the records that show what happened and what changed. Helpful papers include:
- Emergency and follow-up records
- CT, MRI, neuropsychological, or other test results
- A dated symptom diary
- Names of people who noticed changes
- Work or school records that show missed time or changes in how you did
- Any photos, incident reports, and witness information that already exist
Springfield: 185 Belmont Avenue, Springfield, MA 01108
Westfield (Personal Injury Law Center): 56 Washington Street, Westfield, MA 01085
24-hour injury line: (413) 426-8657