Short answer: You may still get workers’ compensation benefits if your Massachusetts employer had no workers comp insurance. The Massachusetts Workers’ Compensation Trust Fund may pay a claim that is approved. On some construction jobs, the insurance company for the contractor above your employer may have to pay instead.
You may also be able to sue the employer with no insurance directly. That lawsuit is separate from a claim for workers’ compensation benefits.
Dunn & Phillips, P.C. has represented injured people in Massachusetts for over 30 years. A real person answers our injury line 24 hours a day at (413) 426-8657.
What if my employer has no workers comp insurance in Massachusetts?
There may still be someone who pays. Two facts usually decide who: whether your employer really had no coverage on the day you were hurt, and which contractors stood between your employer and the owner or company running the project.
| Who may pay | What it pays | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Workers’ Compensation Trust Fund | Workers’ compensation benefits on an approved claim, within the limits that apply to the fund | Your employer had to have Massachusetts coverage, did not have it, and is under Massachusetts legal authority (jurisdiction) |
| General contractor or a contractor higher up the chain | Workers’ compensation benefits | An insured contractor hired your employer, who had no insurance, to do work that would have been covered if the contractor’s own employees had done it |
| Lawsuit against the employer with no insurance | Money for harm caused by the work injury | You were an employee, the employer had to provide coverage, and the injury came from your work and happened while you were working |
| Another person or company that caused the injury (a third party) | Money for the harm that party caused | A person or company other than your employer may be legally responsible for the accident |
| Your health insurance | Medical charges your health plan covers | The plan covers the treatment, under its terms and any right it has to be paid back |
These options can overlap, but one cannot take the place of another. The trust fund does not pay a court judgment against your employer. The insurance company of a contractor higher up the chain pays compensation benefits, not every kind of money you could get in a lawsuit.
For questions about the general contractor, other responsible companies, job-site evidence, or safety violations, see Construction Accidents. For a fuller explanation of benefits and the Department of Industrial Accidents process, see Workers' Compensation.
What is the Workers’ Compensation Trust Fund?
It is a Massachusetts fund that pays approved claims against employers who broke the law by not having insurance. The fund can pay workers’ compensation benefits when the employer is under Massachusetts legal authority and did not carry the coverage it had to have.
The fund does not cover every case where an employer had no insurance. You cannot get fund benefits if you have a right to workers’ compensation benefits in another state or place. The fund also does not pay certain extra (enhanced) benefits or interest the law adds.
A claim against the fund starts with a written statement, called a certification, from the Department of Industrial Accidents Office of Insurance. The certification must say that the department’s records show no workers’ compensation policy for the employer on the date you were hurt.
The claim itself is an Employee Claim, Form 110, made to the department’s Office of Claims Administration. The rules require the certification to go with the claim, and a copy of both to go to the department’s Office of Legal Counsel.
Your claim still must show that you were an employee and that the injury was connected to your work. The fund can argue against those points. If it pays, the fund may try to get the money back from the employer that had no insurance.
What if my boss paid me in cash?
Being paid in cash does not on its own take away your rights. A work agreement can be spoken or written. How your boss paid you does not, by itself, decide whether you were an employee.
Cash can make things harder to prove. Other records can show that you worked for the business, such as:
- Texts about pay, schedules, jobs, tools, or rides
- Bank deposits and payment-app records
- Photos of checks, envelopes, time sheets, or job logs
- Messages that show who told you where and how to work
- Names of coworkers, customers, and contractors who saw you working
Having no pay stub does not mean you have no claim. Other records may show how the work was set up.
What if I was told I’m an independent contractor or a 1099 worker?
The label does not decide your status. A 1099 form, an independent-contractor agreement, or the way your boss describes you is evidence, but it is not the final answer.
Under Massachusetts wage laws, a person who does work for a business is generally treated as an employee unless the business proves all three parts of a test. The worker must be free from the business’s control and direction. The work must be outside the business’s usual kind of work. The worker must also run their own established business doing the same type of work.
Whether you are an employee for workers’ compensation is a separate question. A main issue is whether you worked under an agreement to do work and whether the business you say employed you had the right to control the work.
Facts matter more than paperwork. Useful facts can include who set your hours, gave you the job, gave you instructions, watched over your work, and could stop or change your work.
What if I work for a subcontractor?
The contractor above your employer may have to provide compensation benefits. This can apply when an insured contractor hires an independent contractor or subcontractor with no insurance to do the contractor’s work.
The insurance company for the higher contractor may have to pay the benefits you would have been owed if you had worked directly for the company it insures. That insurance company may then try to get the money back from the employer that had no insurance.
This rule depends on the contracts, the type of work, and the insurance in place on the day of the accident. The legal name of each company on the project matters. Nicknames and the writing on trucks may not name the right business.
For claims against other companies or people involved in the accident, see Construction Accidents.
What if my employer says I’m not covered?
The employer’s answer is not the final word. The employer may be wrong about its insurance, about whether you are an employee, or about which contractor’s policy applies.
An Office of Insurance certification shows whether the department’s records list coverage for the employer, under its exact legal name, on the date you were hurt.
Which contractor hired your employer also matters. If your own employer had no insurance, an insured contractor higher up the chain may be responsible for compensation benefits.
If there was no coverage, you may go after the trust fund and may also have a lawsuit against the employer that had no insurance. Using the trust fund does not, on its own, make the fund your employer’s liability insurance company or make you give up the separate lawsuit.
Can I sue my employer if they had no comp insurance?
Yes, if the employer had to provide coverage and did not. You must show that you were an employee and that your injury came from your work and happened while you were working.
In this kind of lawsuit, the employer with no insurance cannot use several defenses that are normally available in an injury case. The employer cannot win just by arguing that you were careless, that a coworker caused the injury, or that you accepted the risk. When the injury came from your work and happened while you were working, the employer also cannot defend itself by saying it was not at fault.
The lack of insurance is part of this lawsuit. The insurance certification, contracts, pay records, work messages, medical records, and papers that show who the employer is are the kind of evidence it rests on.
A lawsuit is different from a trust fund claim. The trust fund pays compensation benefits on approved claims. It does not pay a settlement or judgment in your lawsuit against the employer.
What will the employer argue?
The employer will often argue that you were not an employee or that you were not working when you were hurt. It may point to a 1099, a written agreement, cash payments, the fact that you used your own tools, or your freedom to set your own schedule.
No single label decides the question. For workers’ compensation, the question includes whether you did work under a stated or understood agreement and whether the business had the right to control the work.
The separate Massachusetts employee test used for wage claims asks whether the business can prove all three of these facts:
- You were free from its control and direction, both under the agreement and in real life.
- Your work was outside its usual kind of business.
- You regularly ran your own established business of the same kind.
If the business cannot prove every part of that wage-law test, you are treated as an employee under those wage laws. That test can help show that a business wrongly called you a contractor (misclassification). But whether workers’ compensation covers you must still be decided under workers’ compensation law.
You can bring a compensation claim through the state agency, a lawsuit against the employer with no insurance, or both, when the facts and the law allow it. The right path depends on whether you were an employee, the insurance records, the chain of contractors, and how you got hurt.
What do the fund and the contractor not pay?
They do not pay every loss you could get in a lawsuit for an injury. The trust fund and the insurance company of a contractor higher up the chain pay workers’ compensation benefits, not the usual money awarded in a lawsuit.
The trust fund does not pay a settlement or judgment in a personal injury lawsuit against the employer with no insurance. It also does not pay certain extra (enhanced) compensation or interest the law adds. The insurance company of a contractor higher up the chain also pays only compensation benefits under the contractor-chain rule, not every kind of money a lawsuit can award.
For an explanation of compensation benefits, see Workers' Compensation.
When should I talk to a lawyer about an employer with no workers comp?
Early, if your employer says you are not covered or the facts are not simple. Some claims are simple enough to settle without a lawyer. A free call is the quickest way to find out which kind yours is.
Uninsured-employer claims get complicated when:
- The employer calls you an independent contractor
- You were paid in cash and have few pay records
- The employer uses more than one business name
- A contractor above your employer may have coverage
- The fund argues that the injury did not happen at work
- More than one state may provide benefits
- You are thinking about a lawsuit
- A filing deadline may be close
A case against an employer with no insurance can involve a state agency claim and a lawsuit at the same time. Those claims have different remedies and deadlines.
How long do I have?
A Massachusetts compensation claim generally must be filed within four years. The time starts when you first become aware that your disability is connected to your job.
A claim against the Workers’ Compensation Trust Fund is a compensation claim, so the same general four-year filing period applies. The rules require the insurance certification before the trust fund claim is filed.
A lawsuit against an employer with no insurance has a special twenty-year period. It starts when you first become aware that your disability is connected to your job.
A separate injury claim against another responsible person or company generally has a three-year deadline. That shorter time can run out while a claim against the employer or the trust fund is still open.
The longest possible deadline does not apply to every claim. Who you are claiming against and the type of claim decide the filing period. Symptoms that show up later, and not being sure the injury came from work, can affect when a time period starts. But they do not make waiting safe.
What should I do first after a work injury if my employer has no workers comp?
Three things protect you whatever happens next.
- Get medical care, and tell your health care provider how you got hurt and that it happened while you were working.
- Keep everything: pay records, tax forms, texts, schedules, job instructions, photos, coworkers’ names, and every letter you get about the injury.
- Do not sign anything from your employer or an insurance company, and do not give a recorded statement, before you have talked to a lawyer.
Some deadlines after a work injury are much shorter than others, so it is worth calling early.
Where we come in
We find out what the department’s records show about your employer’s coverage and trace the chain of contractors above it, to find every policy and fund that may pay. We gather the proof that you worked there, prepare and file the compensation claim, and keep track of the deadline for each separate claim.
We do not recommend handling a claim against an uninsured employer on your own. Do yourself a favor and talk with a workers’ compensation attorney first.
Construction accident lawyers serving Massachusetts
Dunn & Phillips, P.C. serves injured workers across Massachusetts.
Communities served include Springfield, Westfield, Chicopee, Holyoke, West Springfield, Agawam, Ludlow, Longmeadow, Northampton, and Amherst.
The firm has represented injured people in Massachusetts for over 30 years. For other construction-accident questions, including claims involving contractors and other responsible parties, see Construction Accidents.
Talk to us about your injury
Bring the records that show your work and the construction project. Helpful items include pay records or texts about pay, the job-site address, the names of contractors on site, and your medical bills.
Springfield: 185 Belmont Avenue, Springfield, MA 01108
Westfield (Personal Injury Law Center): 56 Washington Street, Westfield, MA 01085
24-hour injury line: (413) 426-8657